Business Owners Idea Cafe: Small Business Information, Resources & Tips
! Small business ideas, information & resources !
Small Business Tax Center
Small Business Ideas, Grants &
Plans to Start & Run a Business:

Small Business Grants
Network in Cyberschmooz Community Ask Questions Questions and Answers Share Tips

Small Business Ideas People in Biz - Profiles
Business Advice from Idea Cafe Experts Coffee Talk with Experts
Starting A Business
Running your Business
Take Out Info
Trade Publications FREE Trade Publications
Your Own Business
About Idea Cafe
Press Idea Cafe has received Idea Cafe in the News
Idea Cafe's Kudos Kudos for Idea Cafe
Advertise on Idea Cafe Advertise on Idea Cafe
Privacy Policy Privacy Policy
Contact Idea Cafe Contact Idea Cafe
Link to Idea Cafe Link to/from Idea Cafe
Join Idea Cafe
Site Directory
Site Directory Site Map Find a Business, Person, or
    Directions at SMARTpages

Online directory to business resources Biz Web Guide
[ Lobby ] [ Main ] [ Help ] [ Search Archives ]

"Short article on "empoyee" vs. "contractor""

Table of Contents
(Just scroll down to see the text of all messages)

Short article on "empoyee" vs. "contractor", Tony Novak, 07:34:55, 8/09/2001
Employee/Indepedent Contractor, Violet, 12:33:20, 8/25/2001, (#1)
Non-Covered Employee Contracting, Bertil Axelsson, 14:20:08, 10/04/2001, (#2)
Reply to "Non-Covered Employee Contracting&qu..., Violet M. Piehl, 13:18:18, 10/14/2001, (#3)


"Short article on "empoyee" vs. "contractor""
Posted by Tony Novak on 07:34:55 8/09/2001
by Tony Novak,

Small business owners and self-employed individuals often need to deal with the complicated and often confusing issue of distinguishing between �employee� and �independent contractor� status. This issue is especially important to the growing number of individuals working from home. Usually the goal of the businessperson is to justify an independent contractor status while the IRS prefers to assert an employer/employee relationship for wage tax purposes. But you may wish to retain eligibility for certain employee benefit plans, even if you may be considered a contractor for wage tax purposes.

There are potentially serious consequences for making a mistake in this area. If the IRS reclassifies a worker as an employee, the employer may owe all of the retroactive wage taxes immediately � even those not collected from the worker! There may be additional interest and tax penalties. When a mistake is discovered in an employee benefit plan, the plan administrator may refuse to convey benefits to a worker who is not eligible for the benefit. This could be disastrous in the case of a business life insurance or health insurance plan. Since there are no absolute rules in this area of business management, it is always wise to consult with your own financial and tax adviser.

The rules used to determine status for wage tax purposes do not apply for eligibility in employee benefit plans. It is possible to be considered eligible for an employee benefit plan but actually be treated as a contractor for wage tax purposes. The opposite is also true � you may not be eligible for employee benefits but still be considered an employee for tax purposes. Determining eligibility for employee benefits is actually much easier � this is stated clearly in the written plan description for each individual employee benefit. Just be careful not to assume that the classification for one issue has any effect on the determination for another purpose.

If your goal is to make sure that a work arrangement is really a contractor relationship, the most effective thing you can do is to send a letter to your contractor which details the relationship and addresses each of the topics addressed below. Get the other party to acknowledge the letter and to hold a copy of the letter in their records as well. Best of all worlds is to have a written contract in which the topics in my letter would be incorporated. In either case, make sure you DO what you write.

These 20 factors are taken from IRS Revenue Ruling 87﷓41. There is no set number of factors that must be in your favor, so the idea is to get as much insurance as possible. We suggest that you meet 15 out of 20 of the factors in your favor to be �safe�.

1. Does the principal provide instructions to the worker about when, where, and how he or she is to perform the work?
2. Does the principal provide training to the worker?
3. Are the services provided by the worker integrated into the principal's business operations?
4. Must the services be rendered personally by the worker?
5. Does the principal hire, supervise and pay assistants to the worker?
6. Is there a continuing relationship between the principal and the worker?
7. Does the principal set the work hours and schedule?
8. Does the worker devote substantially full time to the business of the principal?
9. Is the work performed on the principal's premises?
10. Is the worker required to perform the services in an order or sequence set by the principal?
11. Is the worker required to submit oral or written reports to the principal?
12. Is the worker paid by the hour, week, or month?
13. Does the principal pay the business or traveling expenses of the worker?
14. Does the principal furnish significant tools, materials and equipment?
15. Does the worker have a significant investment in facilities?
16. Can the worker realize a profit or loss as a result of his or her services?
17. Does the worker provide services for more than one firm at a time?
18. Does the worker make his or her services available to the general public?

19. Does the principal have the right to discharge the worker at will?
20. Can the worker terminate his or her relationship with the principal any time he or she wishes without incurring liability to the principal?

If you cannot easily meet the standards of this 20-point test, don�t worry yet. There is another �safe harbor� provision added to the tax law a few years ago. If you can show that a substantial portion of your industry uses sub-contractors in the same status as your particular position, then you are safe in considering yourself also as a sub-contractor. The difficulty in relying on this safe harbor test is that you need to be reactive to your industry and the IRS, rather than be pro-active in designing your business relationships for the effect that you desire.

This article expresses the sole opinion of the author Tony Novak, a tax and benefits adviser with handles online benefits enrollment. E-mail comments and questions welcome at taxplanner@ Novak provides tax and benefits consulting services nationwide to individuals and small businesses. The article is based on sources believed to be reliable, but cannot be guaranteed.


1. "Employee/Indepedent Contractor"
Posted by Violet on 12:33:20 8/25/2001
I have been working on a very special system which will be a great help not only to contractors and independent contractors, but to many others as well. I would like a chance to provide you more information on this system (which I currently have a patent pending for) so that maybe you can assist me in finding funding to get the necessary unique software program developed and market my system.

Very briefly, it is an escrow tax system for a third party escrow tax manager to help the independent contractors set asside the appropriate funds for estimated tax payments, and submitt them timely to tax authorities, eliminating extensive penalty and intrest charges. I believe it will also help the contractors from having their independent contractors be reclassified as employees. Thanks for your time.

I feel this issue is more crucial than most business owners realize, and I feel my system is desperaely needed.


2. "Non-Covered Employee Contracting"
Posted by Bertil Axelsson on 14:20:08 10/04/2001
This may be a little more than a direct response to your question. I suggest send for more information to possibly prevent problems now and in the future .
* This will provide invaluable insight to the unique advantages of Non-Covered Employee Contracting. Under this increasingly popular and lawful working arrangement, both business owner and worker benefit greatly;
* The business owner is relieved of the onerous burdens of payroll administration while at the same time saving thousands of dollars each year on each worker;
* The worker takes home 100% of his paychecks, and can take care of his own retirement and other benefits at far lower cost.
To find out more, tell me where you found this and send me your name and email address.
Bertil Axelsson


3. "Reply to "Non-Covered Employee Contracting""
Posted by Violet M. Piehl on 13:18:18 10/14/2001
Please send me the information on Non-Covered Employee Contracting. Your response was to a notice I posted on the billboard of Cyberschmooz which was in response to an issue about Employee/Independent Contractor.

To re-iterate I have been working on a tax escrow system (PATENT-PENDING) to resolve the imense chore of estimating an accurate tax liability and a feasible method for the independent contractors to have their estimated tax liabilities allocated and timely distributed to the tax authorities.

I hope to hear more about your system. It appears that we are trying to help the same market, and possibly our systems would work very well together. Please contact me at directly. Thank you for your interest.


Jump to Another Forum

[ Back to CyberSchmooz Choose Your Schmooz LOBBY ]  


Rules you agree to in Idea Cafe's CyberSchmooz Forum:
Please use this forum to inform and help your fellow small business owners and entrepreneurs. You are welcome to your opinions... but please refrain from unrelated topics. No advertising or impersonating another real person. We reserve the right to remove any entry we think inappropriate. By posting on this forum, you are agreeing to receive a complimentary issue if Idea Cafe's email newsletter, and you are granting Idea Cafe license to reprint your post in full or in part in any media, copyright Idea Cafe. Idea Cafe does not necessarily agree with or condone any information or suggestions posted on this forum. Idea Cafe Inc, its advertisers, and representatives are not responsible for comments posted here on any damage resulting from them in any way.

©1997-1998 by DCScripts. All rights reserved.

Idea Cafe HomeCyberSchmooz HomeContact UsPrivacy PolicySite Map

Copyright 1995-2007, Idea Cafe Inc. Downloads are for personal use only, not for resale to others, and may not be reprinted in any form without written permission from Idea Cafe Inc.

DISCLAIMER: We hope whatever you find on this site is helpful, but be cautioned that it may not apply to your own situation, or be totally current at any given time. Idea Cafe Inc. and all of its current and past experts, sponsors, advertisers, agents, contractors and advisors disclaim all warranties with regard to anything found anywhere on this family of websites, quoted from, or sent from Idea Cafe, Inc. and its related sites, publications and companies. We also take no responsibility for comments published by others on these pages.