Expert Answers to Biz Questions
Listen in! Pick up some expert advice to a reader's question that we selected from CyberSchmooz.
The Biz Question
I've been looking at Idealab or Ideafactory as far as support, that will make ideas happen fluidly. My question is, anybody had any experiences with either? What are the advantages of working with them rather than doing it "on your own"? It also seems to me that Idealab is more corporate. Thanks.
Answer from our Guest Expert Peter Soh of AdviseInc.com
First, since Idealab and Ideafactory are business incubators, let's define what a business incubator is for those who aren't sure what they do.
What a Business Incubator Does for Your Startup
A business incubator provides administrative, technical, marketing, and financial support to startup companies in exchange for equity in the company. In exchange for this equity, the incubator provides a menu of resources for entrepreneurs. Resources could include strategic development, marketing strategies, or a legal team, or in your case, an idea think tank.
As you know, when you're first getting started in business, you can be haunted by an eerie "lone gun" feeling. An incubator helps you break out of that feeling with more confidence. They'll help you avoid many typical mistakes, such inadequate accounting, little or no legal safeguards, and most of all, inadequate capitalization.
How Incubators Get Hatched
Business incubators typically have strong financial backing from pension funds, private equity funds, and accredited investors (investors with net worth of over $1 million). They get started by first-generation entrepreneurs like Bill Gross, founder of Knowledge Adventure (Idealab); David Weatherall, founder of College Marketing Group (CMGI@Ventures); and Skye Dayton, founder of Earthlink, (ECompanies).
Idealab: The Cream of the California Crop
Since I'm more familiar with Idealab, I'll focus on them. Idealab is a Pasadena-based incubator founded by Bill Gross, a Caltech graduate. It's considered one of the preeminent business incubators in Southern California. Gross, who developed several companies before starting Idealab, decided to create an environment for ideas to grow into businesses. Its primary focus is still the B2C (business to consumer model) and it has been on the leading edge of ecommerce since its inception in 1996.
Idealab (www.idealab.com) currently houses 50 or so companies. It has helped spawn Goto.com, Carsdirect.com, eToys, and NetZero. It still remains to be seen if its companies will be successful since many of its companies have yet to turn a profit, but then again, Amazon.com has yet to turn a profit!
Before considering an incubator, here are a few pros and cons to chew over.
The Bright Side to Business Incubators
Business incubators are good news for many startups because:
The Dark Side to Business Incubators
Be careful of business incubators because:
So if you're willing to give up a degree of control in your company in return for needed infrastructure, creativity, or referrals for investors, I'd recommend Idealab or another business incubator.
It remains to be seen if these incubator companies will succeed in the marketplace as a viable alternative to the traditional ways that companies develop. So far, these incubators have helped some of "their" startups go public. But that's often a mixed blessing with Wall Street's recent bashing of ecommerce stocks! Weigh your options and see if you'd rather "go it alone" rather than risk losing more control of your company than you'd like.
Hope this helps you decide whether or not to use a business incubator. Good luck!
Peter Soh of AdviseInc.com
Have a biz question of your own? Go post it in CyberSchmooz
Meet the Experts
Copyright 1995-2023, Idea Cafe Inc. Downloads are for personal use only, not for resale to others, and may not be reprinted in any form without written permission from Idea Cafe Inc. DISCLAIMER: We hope whatever you find on this site is helpful, but be cautioned that it may not apply to your own situation, or be totally current at any given time. Idea Cafe Inc. and all of its current and past experts, sponsors, advertisers, agents, contractors and advisors disclaim all warranties with regard to anything found anywhere on this family of websites, quoted from, or sent from Idea Cafe. and its related sites, publications and companies. We also take no responsibility for comments published by others on these pages. TRADEMARKS: The following are Registered Trademarks or Servicemarks of DevStart, Inc.: Idea Cafe®, Online Coffee Break®, The Small Business Gathering Place®, Take out Info®, Biz Bar & Grill®, Complaint-O-Meter®, A Fun Approach to Serious Business, CyberSchmooz, and BizCafe.